Persistent and anti-persistent stride-to-stride fluctuations: an ARFIMA decomposition consistent with closed-loop sensorimotor control

Original Abstract

Stride-to-stride fluctuations in human walking carry a fractal correlation structure that reverses sign under external cueing: self-paced gait is persistent, whereas metronomic or visually cued gait is anti-persistent. Three decades of detrended fluctuation analysis (DFA) have established this reversal as a scaling-exponent shift, but DFA cannot distinguish genuine long-memory dynamics from short-memory autoregressive moving-average (ARMA) processes that produce the same apparent exponent. We fit the full eight-model ARFIMA(1,d,1) family to stride interval and stride speed series from three independent datasets (N = 70 subjects) spanning overground walking, fixed-speed treadmill walking, metronomic and visual cueing, and graded positional constraint. Model evidence is aggregated through BIC-based Schwarz weights, and the fractional differencing parameter d together with the autoregressive and moving-average coefficients phi and theta are estimated by Bayesian model averaging. Three findings emerge. Long-memory specifications decisively outweigh ARMA alternatives under both persistent and anti-persistent conditions, establishing cued gait anti-persistence as a genuine fractional phenomenon. DFA alpha overestimates d + 0.5 by 0.25 to 0.34 alpha units owing to short-memory components that DFA conflates with long-memory persistence, establishing ARFIMA-based decomposition as the more informative estimator. The estimated (d, phi, theta) parameters are consistent with a corrective sensorimotor model in which a fractal intrinsic generator, a reactive feedback correction, and a motor-delay component together shape stride-interval fluctuations, with the strength of the correction varying according to the type and tightness of external constraint. A unified mechanistic account of these parameter ranges across rhythmic, spatial, and unconstrained conditions remains an open question.