AI Governance under Political Turnover: The Alignment Surface of Compliance Design
TLDR
A model reveals how AI governance, designed for compliance, can be strategically exploited by future governments, making AI adoption hard to reverse.
Key contributions
- Develops a formal model for AI governance in public administration, considering automation, codification, and safeguards.
- Identifies conditions where AI systems become vulnerable to strategic exploitation by governments.
- Explains why initial oversight reforms can paradoxically increase long-term vulnerability.
- Shows why expansions in AI use, once embedded, may become difficult to unwind.
Why it matters
This research is crucial for understanding the long-term risks of integrating AI into public administration. It reveals how well-intentioned governance designs can be subverted by political turnover, leading to unintended and irreversible consequences. It provides a framework for designing more robust AI compliance systems.
Original Abstract
Governments are increasingly interested in using AI to make administrative decisions cheaper, more scalable, and more consistent. But for probabilistic AI to be incorporated into public administration it must be embedded in a compliance layer that makes decisions reviewable, repeatable, and legally defensible. That layer can improve oversight by making departures from law easier to detect. But it can also create a stable approval boundary that political successors learn to navigate while preserving the appearance of lawful administration. We develop a formal model in which institutions choose the scale of automation, the degree of codification, and safeguards on iterative use. The model shows when these systems become vulnerable to strategic use from within government, why reforms that initially improve oversight can later increase that vulnerability, and why expansions in AI use may be difficult to unwind. Making AI usable can thus make procedures easier for future governments to learn and exploit.
📬 Weekly AI Paper Digest
Get the top 10 AI/ML arXiv papers from the week — summarized, scored, and delivered to your inbox every Monday.