The splash beneath the largest radio bubble in a cluster core
H. R. Russell, P. E. J. Nulsen, A. C. Fabian, B. R. McNamara, J. S. Sanders + 1 more
TLDR
XRISM observations of the Ophiuchus cluster reveal modest gas motions and turbulence in a giant radio bubble's wake, insufficient to prevent rapid cooling.
Key contributions
- XRISM detected a -80 km/s velocity shift and increased dispersion (135 to 210 km/s) in the Ophiuchus bubble wake.
- Velocity shift and dispersion increase are concentrated in the wake's center, consistent with an updraft 'splash'.
- Turbulent kinetic energy is only 1% of thermal energy over 7 Gyr, insufficient to prevent rapid cooling.
- Despite the giant radio bubble, gas motions are modest, and turbulent-dissipation heating is 3x below cooling.
Why it matters
This study provides direct measurements of gas dynamics in a massive cluster's core using XRISM. It shows that even the largest radio bubbles may not generate enough turbulence to prevent rapid cooling, challenging assumptions about AGN feedback.
Original Abstract
We present a 100 ks XRISM Resolve observation of the Ophiuchus cluster that measures turbulence and bulk motion in the wake of the largest radio bubble on the sky. We detect a significant velocity shift of $-80\pm20$ km/s from the cluster centre to the bubble's wake and a clear increase in velocity dispersion from $135\pm10$ km/s to $210\pm20$ km/s. The measured bulk velocity in the wake is low and suggests that the bubble's trajectory is inclined with respect to the line of sight. If we subdivide the bubble's wake, fitting spectra simultaneously with cross-region responses, we find that the velocity shift and dispersion increase are primarily detected in the very centre of the wake. This is consistent with the expected updraft, or `splash', found beneath buoyantly rising radio bubbles. In the cluster's cool core, the turbulent kinetic energy is only 1% of the thermal energy radiated over a cooling timescale of 7 Gyr, and even falls short, by a factor of 5, of the thermal energy radiated over the bubble's rise time. Whilst turbulent energy generated in the large wake region may provide additional heating, this propagates too slowly to prevent rapid cooling across the core. The turbulent-dissipation heating rate is a factor of ~3 below the cooling luminosity. Despite the vast power of the giant radio bubble in the Ophiuchus cluster, the gas motions in the wake are remarkably modest and turbulent-dissipation appears unable to prevent rapid cooling.
📬 Weekly AI Paper Digest
Get the top 10 AI/ML arXiv papers from the week — summarized, scored, and delivered to your inbox every Monday.